Chess is more than Playing Chess

August 22nd, 2010 by rick No comments »

I’ve been organizing events for kids for a few years now and have come to the conclusion that Scholastic Chess is much more than “Kids Playing Chess”.  In addition to learning how to play a board game, Chess is also about sportsmanship, fair play, individual achievement, team contribution, learning to win, learning to lose, being our best, learning from our mistakes and learning to “be our own advocate”. It’s this last item I want to touch on.

[NOTE: The following does not apply to very young children (Kindergarten). Some would argue that 1st grade falls into this category but let's leave that for a different discussion.]

When I coach my clubs, I do my best to teach kids all of the above but most importantly, to be responsible for their own results. I’m always amazed that when you have the chance to let a child be accountable and EXPECT IT, they will (9 times out of 10) raise to the occasion and give us, as parents, the opportunity to praise and reward them.

When a child plays in a tournament, we expect THEM to be accountable for the results and to make sure they are properly recorded. We do this for a couple of reasons. Most importantly – THEY own the result. We teach them that they can stand up for themselves if something is wrong and work things out (yes, with supervision). I’m never more proud when 2 kids are having a disagreement over something and they have the chance to work it out themselves. Almost every time, they come to the right decision and feel proud that they resolved it themselves.

As parents, we naturally want to be their advocate and support them. We have a very important job in this respect; however, we also have to provide a place for them to stand up for themselves and be accountable for taking (or not taking) action. If something is wrong (and yes, sometimes mistakes happen), we need to use the mistake as a way of helping them recognize issues and take the right actions. By allowing our kids to do this themselves, we do them a far greater service than getting a point in an event, we teach them how to stand up for themselves.

As parents, we need to encourage our kids to be responsible for their own issues on the chess floor and support the advocacy of themselves. We need to find those teachable moments and let them rise and fall. We must stand behind them but let them know that it’s their job – not ours – to address concerns.  THAT is a gift that is more valuable than any trophy.

Some thoughts on Championships

August 4th, 2010 by rick 1 comment »

There was a lot of discussion last year about the structure of State Championships. Within each grade, we have so many kids that some “Sections” are larger than entire Tournaments! These numbers lead to a situation than many are uncomfortable with – tiebreaks being used to determine the place of the player.

Tiebreaks are a computer generated ranking based on a mathematical formula of the relative strength of players winning the same number of games (or points). The problem with tiebreaks is that the player has no control over them – who they play or how they are ranked.

Last year, at the end of State, there were 249 in a single section. “Place” trophies (ie: 14th place) are given to the top 30 places.In the 3rd grade, places 10 thru 39 were held by players that won 4 games out of 5. That meant that there were 9 players that did not receive a “Place Trophy” for no other reason than they were “unlucky” in who the computer paired them with.

In addition, those players at the top never had the opportunity to prove that they were “the best in the State”. K-3 National Champion Roland Feng received “2nd place” not because he played poorly (he won all his games), but that the players he was paired against were not as strong as the players William Lee (who received 1st Place) was paired against. 4 players were undefeated and yet some were placed higher than others.

On the other side of the argument, by having more kids in each section, you allow “stronger” kids to play “weaker” kids and the “stronger” ones can win more games than they would otherwise.

Both positions have value but here is the question:

Should STATE be a “Championship” or should it be a “Festival”?

A CHAMPIONSHIP is an event that generates a winner – someone that is “the best in the state” whereas a FESTIVAL is an event that allows as many people to enjoy themselves.

Both are valid. The question we must ask is “Which one do we want?” I’ve included a little poll for you to make your position (anonymously) heard.  If you are entering “OTHER”, please include a comment explaining what your thoughts.

February Events for Middle School

January 25th, 2010 by rick No comments »

February has few events for Middle School this year – but there ARE events! Here are two you should consider….

  • The Northwest Grade Level at Bryant Elementary (Seattle) on 2/6 has a special 7-8 section. Let’s bring a BUNCH of us and show everyone that we have a strong community that supports Middle School!
  • The WA State Bughouse Championship in Lynnwood on 2/13 is a fun event for all with a K-12 section for older kids. No need to have a partner, we will match you up with someone at registration.

Both events can be found at www.chess4life.com

Clocks and “Stalling”

October 23rd, 2009 by rick 2 comments »

A number of parents have begun discussing a trend that is happening with greater frequency – “Stalling for the clock”. We find that a small but growing number of children are using a tactic of deliberately using up time until there are 20 minutes left in the round, at which time, a clock is placed on the board and a player that may be unfamiliar with using a clock is forced to play very quickly. We believe this is  unsportsmanlike behavior. It attempts to use “the system” to their advantage in a manner it was never intended for.

There are different opinions within the community. Some believe that this is not a big deal, others, see it as larger problem, still others think its an issue that there is no good solution for. It’s a difficult issue but one in which we have an obligation to provide a fair environment for all.

This issue was brought to the Board for discussion. At the meeting, there was unanimous agreement that “Stalling” was considered to be “Unsportsmanlike behavior” and should be discouraged. The Board also reaffirmed the practice of allowing judges to use their discretion to provide a warning or place a clock on the board to assure that a fair environment is maintained.

We are also examining the rights of players to use a clock and to try to find ways to encourage the use of clocks at the State Tournament. These topics will be discussed more during the year. Ideas include:

  • Allowing the right of a player in grades 2 and 3 to request the use of a clock (just like Grades 4-6 today),
  • Providing “Tournament Clocks” to be requested by players (on an as available basis). This will increase the likelihood that a child will be required to play with a clock.
  • Require clocks to be used on Top boards

Currently, Nationals required clocks to be used on all rated games. Part of what we are looking at is the idea of how we can raise the standard of Chess in WA State and provide a fairer environment for all.

We welcome everyone’s input and want to hear if this is something we should adjust for or not. We welcome your thoughts, for, against, or neutral. We want to hear from you so we can make an event that serves the needs of the community.

NEW SITE AND DATE for 2011!

October 23rd, 2009 by rick 2 comments »

Welcome everyone! After much negotiation and discussion over the summer, we have new information on the location AND DATE for the 2011 State Elementary Chess Championships. We will be hosting the event at the Tacoma Convention Center on April 30th, 2011. Both of these are changes from the original bid for a number of reasons explained below.

We selected the Convention Center for the bid initially because it was the only site that allowed us to house everyone we expected under a single roof. We were able to secure 105,000 sq ft. with the expectation that we would be able to get more. When that failed to occur, we went to “Plan B” – the Bellevue College. Unfortunately, at the last minute, we were unable to get a reasonable date in April other than Easter Weekend. After much discussion and consultation with the Board, we asked, and received permission from the Board to hold it at the Tacoma Convention Center for 2011 (as well as 2010).

The Tacoma Convention Center is the second largest facility in the area (after the WA State Convention Center) and we believe will be an ideal venue for the event. A separate discussion about the thinking that went into allowing this to occur is posted HERE.

We hope these changes are seen as positive for the community. We know there are a number of issues that will arise from this change of venue and we hope that you make your comments public on this blog – both positive and negative. WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU! Help us make this the best event possible!

Welcome!

September 20th, 2009 by admin No comments »

Welcome to the Mountlake Terrace Community Chess Club Web Site!

Here, you can see the various activities we support and promote. Please sign up for our newsletter and surveys. As hosts for the 2011 State event, we are actively soliciting participation from the community as to how best we can make State the best event ever!

We also support and sponsor Middle School Chess in Washington. You can link to www.middleschoolchess.com here.